[Brin]

Hi TRDG,

I would suggest a little bit of both, from contemporary reports; apparently Bismarck had fired two ranging shots to the f'wd and aft of Hood. Meanwhile Hood and PoW were steaming in a straight line charge at the Bismarck to close the range. Albeit fairly close together, making it easier for the German gunners to target, whilst foolishly restricting manoeuvrability. The aiming of the fated salvo from Bismarck was probably assisted by a fire that had broken out on the Hood, apparently caused by one of the Prinz Eugen's earlier salvos.

I appreciate that the skirmish theory posted earlier is different to many published theories of Holland attempting to engage in a set piece battle. But to my mind, if Holland wanted to do such, why leave out half of your forces, namely Suffolk and Norfolk? Both of which were within striking distance and were waiting on the order to attack the Prinz Eugen (in accordance with the initial plan), having maintained radar contact for most of the night before.

Or is this a classic case of Holland underestimating his foes and trying to ‘grab’ the glory?

Unfortunately those of the immediate command team went down with the Hood, so speculation remains. Of the three survivors none would have been in a position to have involvement in any of the planning or decision stages. Although Briggs may have witnessed Holland's realisation of his folly leading to the final situation for the Hood.